The AI questions have changed
For two years, almost every conversation I had about AI started in roughly the same place: where are the opportunities? What are the priority use cases for us? How fast can we take them? Who is ahead?

That conversation has not gone away, but it is no longer the only one.
A friend of mine, John Metselaar, is Professor of Management Practice at the Solvay Brussels School and leads The Conference Board’s Global Innovate & Transform Institute. He spends much of his time with senior leaders across industries. He told me that in recent months he has noticed two AI-related questions appearing more often in those conversations. Neither is about opportunity.
The first question is personal.
Leaders are starting to experience AI not just as something they deploy, but as something they personally have to lead. Can I do what is being asked of me? How am I supposed to lead this when I don’t know where it is going? And what am I actually leading towards?
A consultant can map use cases. A vendor will happily create you a rollout roadmap. But whether you can keep a team together through a change whose destination is still unclear is your problem alone. Many leaders still feel they should look as if they have it all figured out, but nobody has. I believe leaders today should be learners instead: they should jump in, learn and grow with the change, and then inspire their people to do the same.
In any case, the uncertainty is real. A survey published this spring found that 73 percent of CEOs reported stress or anxiety about their company’s AI strategy.1 It is a vendor-sponsored survey, so I would not put too much weight on the number, but the direction feels correct.
The second question is even harder.
Interestingly, John and I are both seeing more and more leaders ask themselves questions that have not been part of management conversations before:
What will people do when a growing share of the work is done by machines? What will we be valued for as employees and humans? What will make someone feel that they have done something worthwhile at the end of a day? At the end of a life?
Not long ago, those questions belonged mostly to philosophers and psychologists. At the current pace of AI development, they are fast becoming management questions, with very concrete consequences for the business.
Researchers have described how AI is taking over many of the small, checklist-style tasks that used to give people a sense of progress: emails answered, documents processed and summarised, analyses completed.2 People may end up doing more while feeling that they have accomplished less. Some may even feel a kind of guilt about no longer doing parts of their jobs themselves.
I don’t think that is simply a productivity problem. There is something deeper going on. With the typical AI productivity hacks, we are removing some of the everyday achievements that used to tell people their work matters. That is probably already affecting their motivation.
That is part of the reason why I am not optimistic about the next few years, without even going down the rabbit hole of doomsday scenarios. It seems inevitable that this will get worse as AI moves from automating small tasks here and there to replacing ever larger parts of people’s jobs.
Another perspective
I’m grateful to John for pointing me towards a counterweight: a book he recommended, Angus Fletcher’s Primal Intelligence. Although I wouldn’t recommend that book without reservation, I found it uplifting. It argues that four deeply human capabilities (common sense, intuition, imagination and emotion) cannot be replicated by machines, because they are not computations that can be calculated and statistically calibrated, but physiological processes rooted in our biology. Common sense, for example, involves knowing when you do not know, which, Fletcher argues, an AI cannot recognise by itself. Some of the neuroscience in the book is shaky, to say the least, and the constant anecdotes from the US military really annoyed me. But that particular idea has stayed with me, and has given me something to think about and hope for.
In an AI transformation, admitting that you don’t know is not a failure. It may be one of the few things a leader can model for their people that the technology cannot.
What then?
The two questions we’ve raised are different in kind: the first is about the leader’s ability to navigate the change and the second is about what the change means for the people they lead, and for themselves. But they meet in the same place: the person at the front of the room, whom everyone in the team looks to for guidance, and who is at the same time part of the situation.
People watch what a leader does when there is no obvious answer. They sense intuitively whether uncertainty produces hidden panic, denial or rash action. And most leaders, privately, are dealing with the very same uncertainty and doubts as their employees.
There is some evidence that leadership changes how people experience AI. Gallup data from the US suggests that workers who use AI more frequently are more concerned about losing their jobs, except where they experience well-structured management.3 The technology may be the same, but the experience of it isn’t.
In practice, this is relatively simple, but not easy. You name the question instead of rushing to close it, and admit to your team that you do not know the answer, at least not yet. You tell your team what you know now, and what you don’t. You are clear about how you will make decisions under the uncertainty, even when you cannot yet say exactly what those decisions will be.
That is all the more difficult when the board is breathing down your neck, wanting a roadmap, concrete implementation proposals and regular status updates, while the employees want certainty and clear answers. But dealing with uncertainty is a profound leadership capability, and like most capabilities it can be practised only in the hardship of the situation itself. Meaning: now.
I would even argue that leading under uncertainty is probably the most essential leadership skill of them all.
John sent me a line he had heard recently, to stress this point: “Become comfortable by being uncomfortable.” This applies to leaders, but also to whole organisations, which will have to adapt to a world that is becoming far less predictable. That is really uncomfortable. In Europe, in particular, we have become addicted to stability and comfort over the decades. I believe those days are gone for good. Leaders had better wake up and also shake things up.
This is where I think leadership work becomes interesting: it is not a leader’s job to produce yet another AI-generated AI strategy. Their value lies in helping the people who have to carry the uncertainty in daily operations to see a perspective that goes beyond the fear of losing their jobs. It will also help them see value in their work and find purpose, even if their jobs are genuinely under threat.
John shared a slide with me, inspired by Amy Edmondson, that he uses with his EMBA students: the conventional understanding of strategy is that of a rigid planning exercise, in which a small leadership group, convinced it knows it all, makes the “strategic” decisions in advance. Today, however, strategy needs to become a learning process with guiding principles, a sense of direction and a set of questions that are refined and answered on the way. Strategy becomes emergent. Henry Mintzberg already argued decades ago that strategies often emerge rather than being planned. Already back in business school, I found this much more compelling than the crystal-ball approach of strategic planning. Now, that view is more applicable than ever.
There is nothing wrong with putting AI opportunities, use cases and forward-looking business plans in strategy decks. But that really is the easy part.
The hard part, unfortunately, is for the people who must lead the change. But that is also, I think, where a leader can make the biggest difference for their organisation, as by now, most competitors have found the same use cases for AI and are working on them, too. Whether they succeed depends on whether their teams have also learnt how to move through uncertainty.
I’ll give the last word to John by borrowing an image he shared with me: a change of this size is like a wave. You can get swamped by it, or you can learn to ride it. I’d add just one thing: teach your people to ride it, too.


